Southampton Town Board debates rental subsidy program, sets budget hearings

The board weighed a Nantucket-style program paying landlords up to $27,000 to convert rentals to year-round housing, without deciding.

A frame from the Town of Southampton Town Board meeting recording
From the public recording of the Town of Southampton Town Board meeting · watch this moment

The Southampton Town Board on Thursday scheduled a series of public hearings for next week, including on the preliminary 2027 town budget, amending the town's tax levy, changes to the Landmarks and Historic District Board, a Jackson Avenue Civic Master Plan, a Riverside Hamlet design pattern book, and acquisition of a Noyac property through the Community Preservation Fund.

Board members spent much of the meeting discussing whether to bring PlaceMate's 'Lease to Locals' and 'Rooted Renters' programs to Southampton, incentive programs that pay landlords to convert seasonal rentals into year-round workforce housing. A presenter from PlaceMate told the board that across all of the company's programs nationwide, it has unlocked 970 new units and housed more than 2,000 people since the first program launched in 2020, and said incentives in Nantucket's version of the program can total up to $27,000 per property.

One council member called the approach "a really great imaginative way of utilizing some of the existing housing stock" but asked whether second-home owners who have never rented their properties would qualify. Another council member compared the subsidy to "choosing who gets vouchers" and questioned letting homeowners pick which tenant's rent gets subsidized.

One council member argued the program would put the town "on a much more predictable and stable path of actually housing people that need it, the workforce," compared with having no such guarantee now. But another council member said he worried landlords would raise rents to market rate once a one-year subsidy ended, saying, "my rent's going up to market rate," said he wanted internal data on seasonal rentals before moving forward, and said the public "would have an issue with subsidizing rent for people making up to $300,000 a year" under Nantucket's income cap.

No vote was taken on the rental program. A board member asked staff to get written feedback from the Town of Nantucket on how its version of the program has worked before the town moves forward.

The board also co-sponsored resolutions to purchase firearms, ammunition and less-lethal products from several vendors under state contracts, introduced a notice to proposers for a new Town Justice Court building with bids due Dec. 17, read a resolution to authorize the sale of one town-owned Pine Barrens development-rights credit to an attorney representing Heritage Square Office Condominiums, and co-sponsored spending Community Housing Fund money to acquire and rehabilitate a Hampton Bays property to create 10 permanently affordable rental apartments.

The board also noted that the town's first-time homebuyer down-payment assistance loan program, recently increased to 18% of purchase price, is already drawing several applications.

The board also introduced a notice of hearing on improvements to the Hampton Bays water district, including a new storage tank. Members closed the meeting with updates on a Redwood Marina ribbon cutting in Sag Harbor, a youth leadership summit on mental health, a resource fair for people with special needs, Veterans Day events, a Sustainability Committee report and a hazardous waste collection event, before voting to move into executive session.

Key decisions

  • Introduced a notice to proposers for a new Southampton Town Justice Court building, with bids due Dec. 17.
  • Read a resolution to authorize the sale of one town-owned Pine Barrens development-rights credit to an attorney for Heritage Square Office Condominiums.
  • Scheduled public hearings on the 2027 budget, amending the town's tax levy, Landmarks board changes, Jackson Avenue Civic Master Plan, a Riverside Hamlet pattern book and a Noyac property acquisition.
  • Introduced a notice of hearing on Hampton Bays water district improvements including a storage tank.
  • Voted to enter executive session to discuss acquisitions, legal advice, contracts and litigation.

In their words

“I will just say I think this is a really great imaginative way of utilizing some of the existing housing stock”

“I just feel like they're gonna get tenants in and we know in our market that once you have a rental and you're in there and you got in there with that subsidy, and you have an affordable rent, and then the renter said, and then the landlord says to you, hey, that subsidy was a one-year thing, sorry, but my rent's going up to market rate.”

“I think the public would have a chance, would have an issue with subsidizing rent for people making up to $300,000 a year. I mean, that's kind of crazy to me.”

“It does put us on a much more predictable and stable path of actually housing people that need it, the workforce, and we can then ensure that there's that long-term availability, whereas right now we have nothing that ensures that at all.”

What's next

The board asked staff to obtain written feedback from Nantucket on how its rental incentive program has worked before deciding whether to pursue a similar program, and will hold public hearings next week on the 2027 budget and several other items.

Source

Town of Southampton Town Board · Nov 5, 2026 · Watch the source recording

Corrections: [email protected]